29 November 2020

Swift v Carpenter judgement


As a lawyer specialising in complex and serious injury cases, I was delighted to read the landmark judgement of the English Court of Appeal in Swift v Carpenter (2020). This long-awaited decision outlines a new approach to calculating compensation claims for accommodation costs.

The purpose of an award of damages is to put a person back into the position they would have been but for the accident. Compensation should be fair and reasonable but prior to Swift v Carpenter, it was anything but. The problem was compounded by negative discount rates. This meant claimants who suffered the most serious, life-changing injuries requiring the purchase of alternative suitable accommodation were, for years, inadequately compensated. It is likely Swift will be followed in the Scottish Courts heralding a more equitable solution to a problem that has vexed personal injury lawyers for years.

Where a claimant sustains serious injury, their accommodation may no longer be suitable for their needs. For example, a severe spinal cord injury confining an individual to a wheelchair, renders a two-bed upper flat unsuitable. A property needs to be single storey with additional rooms for carers, storage and a therapy room. If the full additional cost of purchasing alternative accommodation was claimed, that would mean a potential windfall for the claimant’s estate, as property is generally considered to be an appreciating asset.

To avoid such a windfall, Roberts v Johnstone (1989) set out a formula for providing compensation for future accommodation costs based on the loss of the use of capital used to purchase a more expensive suitable property. The claim was set down as the capital difference between the new and existing property x discount rate x life expectancy.

In our example of a two-bedroom unsuitable flat valued at £150,000 and a four-bed bungalow valued at £400,000, pre-2017 and using the R v J formula, the claim for future accommodation costs for a 30-year-old male claimant would be £185,000.

Whilst discount rates remained positive at 2-2.5%, the R v J formula avoided windfall, but a claimant was often forced to use funds from other heads of claim (e.g. future wage loss or compensation for pain and suffering) to make up the shortfall.

From around 2017, with the advent of negative discount rates at -0.75%, the R v J formula proved completely unworkable. Many claimants were unable to recover damages in law for future accommodation costs. This resulted in inadequate levels of damages to those who suffered serious injuries, going against the laid down maxim that damages awarded should be fair and reasonable.

Using the same formula with a negative discount rate of -0.75%, R v J produces an award of -£1,340,000! In other words, nil recovery for future accommodation costs.

Swift sets out to redress the problem (in times of negative discount rates) for a seriously injured person needing larger accommodation. The calculation allows the injured person to claim full extra costs of accommodation less a discount to reflect ‘reversionary interest’. The same example for our 30-year-old male allows him a claim of £233,300 for accommodation costs.

As a personal injury lawyer, acting on behalf of those seriously injured in road traffic collisions, especially motorcyclists, I welcome the Swift decision.

Furthermore, the Court has specified that the formula for calculating accommodation costs should not be seen as a ‘straitjacket’ to be applied universally and rigidly so this leaves scope for the formula to be revisited in the event of a significant change to the discount rate.

Roz Boynton - Solicitor, Road Traffic Accident Law (Scotland) LLP

Read all our latest news


9 June 2022

Big buzz about electric transportation

A new Low speed, Zero Emission Vehicle category is likely to be introduced by DfT in a new Transport Bill. E-scooters are likely to be the first to be introduced within this class. 

Read More >


20 February 2022

The new Highway Code – what’s all the fuss about?

Safe and courteous road users have nothing to worry about as far as the new Highway code rules are concerned


Read More >


16 November 2021

Road Safety Week 2021

RTALS are supporting Road Safety Week 2021 recognising the work undertaken by our Road Safety heroes. 

Read More >


31 October 2021


A defence in automatism has no place in Civil Law

Read More >


2 September 2021

It's all in the balance

Working a 4 day week may sound strange to many, but if a busy Law firm can make it work, then surely others will be able to follow suit.

Read More >


21 March 2021


When it comes to the question of who’s to blame in a road traffic incident, sometimes it is not entirely clear. 

Read More >


26 January 2021

The Courts are getting there virtually

There can be no going backwards now for the Civil courts after accepting a new virtual system for Court hearings.

Read More >


9 December 2020

Independent ethos

Remaining independent is part of our ethos. All our cases are generated organically. We never purchase cases from insurers and we don't work with referral companies. 

Read More >


29 November 2020

Swift v Carpenter judgement

In times of negative discount rates, we finally have a more equitable approach to calculating the costs of accommodation costs thanks to the Swift v Carpenter decision.


Read More >


24 November 2020

Case Law and accidents on icy roads

Compensation claims for road traffic incidents caused by icy roads are inherently difficult to win but a recent case, Smithson v Lynn, has changed this position. 

Read More >


6 October 2020

Behind the mask

Personal injury claimants should beware that insurers are looking at your social media profiles and activity. Of course, what is portrayed is not always representative of what is actually going on 'behind the mask.' 

Read More >


13 May 2020


In this interview with adventurer, speaker and now Champion cyclist, Jaco van Gass, we find out how he overcame the loss of an arm through acceptance and then developed and achieved new goals through positive mental attitude and shear resilience.


Read More >


20 April 2020

It's time to restart our beating heart

Whilst Insurers and Law firms operating within the Civil Justice system in Scotland have successfully adapted their working practices in order to continue to progress cases, the Scottish Courts and Tribunal Service has simply shut up shop.

Read More >


16 April 2020

The Rainbow Children

Rainbows are popping up all across the country and are synonymous with hope and tolerance across the world.

Read More >


9 April 2020

Working from home

Ewen Stewart, Legal Assistant, at RTALS has predominantly worked from home for over 20 years so has plenty of tips for those who are new to homeworking due to Covid-19 restrictions. He has had to make some adjustments to his own way of working though too.

Read More >


1 April 2020

Searching for the positives

When the world seems to have ground to a halt and life as we know it has been put on hold, it can be very easy to feel down and lost. It is important to search for the positives.

Read More >


8 March 2020

Dear Sirs

It's time the use of 'Dear Sirs" as a method of addressing an individual is reviewed. After all, we are in 2020.

Read More >


31 October 2019

Do you trust insurers?

Consumer trust in insurance companies is falling. Would you trust them to appoint a Lawyer in the event of injury following a road traffic collision?

Read More >


29 October 2019

It's getting increasingly technical

For lawyers working in the field of personal injury, keeping abreast of the latest available equipment for an injured client is vital. Complex injuries demand innovative and complex solutions to aid client rehabilitation.

Read More >


Motorcycle Law Scotland Logo

Motorcycle Law Scotland is a unique legal service for injured motorcyclists following a road traffic collision in Scotland. We aim to ensure that motorcyclists and their families receive the best possible legal advice and support.

Our dynamic team of experienced legal experts are also motorcyclists. As specialists, our knowledge of motorcycling incidents, motorcyclists’ needs, motorcycles and the Law is second to none.

We see our clients, and sometimes their family members face to face, so we get to know them well.

Our clients trust us because we speak their language.

Pedestrian Law Scotland

Pedestrian Law Scotland provides specialist personal injury legal representation for pedestrians involved in road traffic incidents in Scotland.

If you've been injured in a road traffic collison as a pedestrian in Scotland within the last three years through no fault of your own, you may be entitled to claim compensation for your loss, injury or damage.

We work on a 'no win no fee' basis and can provide access to justice at no financial risk to you. We will fund your case from start to finish.

Just fill in the contact form or give us a call to discuss your case with one of our specialist Lawyers.

Cycle Law Scotland logo

Cycle Law Scotland is a specialist personal injury legal service for cyclists who have been injured on Scotland's roads through no fault of their own.

The team of legal experts are also all cyclists themselves. As specialists, our knowledge of cycling incidents, cyclists’ needs, bicycles and the Law is second to none.

We like to meet all our clients and sometimes their families personally, so we get to know them well. 

We're passionate about providing the best possible service for our clients and our prime focus is to get them fit again and back on their bikes.

To discuss your potential claim for injury, damage or loss, just contact us.





All correspondence should be addressed or delivered to:
Road Traffic Accident Law (Scotland) LLP
16-20 Castle Street,



If you have been involved in a road traffic collision, you can contact us below at an address nearest to you or if you prefer to use our online enquiry form just give your name and number and one of our specialist lawyers will contact you.



4 Redheughs Rigg Westpoint,
South Gyle,
EH12 9DQ


1 West Regent Street,
G2 1RW



One Marischal Square,
Broad Street,
Aberdeen, AB10 1BL


5 Cherry Court,
Cavalry Park,
Peebles, EH45 9BU